cylive.com | help | tour | contact | sign in | join Cylive
ContentCategoriesCommunity

Web Snippet / Iranian Arrest of British Soldiers - Unanswered Questions

Filed in: News and Events

Tagged with website, social bookmark, link,Iran, Iraq, custody, Britain, UK, sailors, marines, arrest, Iranian, military, soldiers, navy, naval, maritime, territory, territorial, waters

Last Modified May 23, 2008 at 11:04 PM PDT by Antiwar

Viewed 531 time(s)

Rated by 2 Cylivers

As one would expect there is a lack of clarity on whether the Iranians arrested the British marines in Iraqi waters or Iranian waters. Assuming - as the British defence and foreign ministries are leading us to believe - the arrest took place in Iraqi (or international) waters, there are several questions that come up.

1) Why did the British radars not pick up the presence of Iranian naval vessels in (presumably) "Iraqi waters" that they were protecting (or at least supposed to protect)?

2) Why did the British marines surrender so timidly to the Iranians without any resistance? After all, they were supposed to be in Iraqi / international waters and so the Iranians were guilty of violating Iraqi waters.

3) The moment the hostile intentions of the Iranian vessels was known, why did the British marines / sailors not call for air support to deter the Iranian threat (particularly since all this was in Iraqi waters)?

It is quite apparent that truth is the first casualty in any military conflict or crisis of this kind. We really don't get to know what the truth is and who is at fault!

Viewed 531 times Commented 3 times AddThis Social Bookmark Button

rate this content

  • Email This!
  • add Add to my favorites
  • print Print or Export
  • Flag as inappropriate
  • Subscribe to RSS Feed
Search :
Filter results by: =
edit

Snapshot

The page may have changed since the time the snapshot was taken. [go to current page].

 

Iran softens stance on British sailors



By NASSER KARIMI, Associated Press Writer 17 minutes ago

TEHRAN, Iran -

Iran said Monday it was questioning 15 British sailors and marines to determine if their alleged entry into Iranian waters was "intentional or unintentional" before deciding what to do with them — the first sign it could be seeking a way out of the standoff.

The two countries continued to disagree about where the military personnel were seized Friday, with Britain insisting they were in Iraqi waters after searching a civilian cargo vessel and the Tehran regime saying it had proof they were in Iranian territory.

Britain's Defense Ministry said they were seized in the Shatt al-Arab, a waterway flowing into the Persian Gulf that marks the border between Iran and Iraq. But the dividing line in the waterway, known in Iran as the Arvand river, has long been disputed.

The Iranian emphasis Monday on the detainees' intent was a noticeable pullback from the certainty expressed Saturday by Iran's military chief, Gen. Ali Reza Afshar. Afshar said then that the 15 confessed to "aggression into the Islamic Republic of Iran's waters."

Other Iranian officials suggested afterward that the Britons might be charged with a crime — presumably espionage or trespassing — for knowingly entering Iran's territorial waters.

Deputy Foreign Minister Mehzi Mostafavi took a softer line Monday while saying that the 14 men and one woman were still being interrogated. "It should become clear whether their entry was intentional or unintentional. After that is clarified, the necessary decision will be made," Mostafavi said.

Iran has refused to say where the captured Britons were being held or to allow British officials to speak with them, but assured the British ambassador to Tehran, Geoffrey Adams, that they were in good health.

During an official visit to Turkey on Monday, British Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett called for Iran to allow access to the captives. "We will continue to press the Iranian authorities until the incident has been resolved with the safe return of our personnel and their equipment," she said.

In London, Iranian Ambassador Rasoul Movahedian was summoned to the British Foreign Office for the third time since the standoff began. Lord Triesman, Foreign Office undersecretary, again demanded the safe return of the detained personnel, the Foreign Office said.

There were fears in Britain that the fate of the 15 could get caught up in the political tensions between Tehran and the West, including the dispute over Iran's nuclear program and accusations of Iranian help to Shiite militants in Iraq.

In particular, there were worries Iran might seek to use the prisoners as leverage in trying to get the U.S. to free at least five Iranians detained in Iraq for allegedly being part of a Revolutionary Guard force that provides funds, weapons and training to Iraqi Shiite militias.

Mostafavi denied Iran was seeking a trade, but there were calls from elsewhere within Iran's leadership for the government to hold out for a swap.

A Web site run by Mohsen Rezaei, secretary of the Expediency Council and a former Revolutionary Guard commander, quoted an unidentified lawmaker as saying, "If Iranian diplomats in Iraq have no security, there's no reason why we should forgive and turn a blind eye to aggressors into Iranian territories."

Some members of the Iranian public also called for the British sailors and marines to be held and tried. Hundreds of Iranian students demonstrated near the coast to urge a tough stand in the confrontation with the West.

British leaders sought to play down fears the situation could escalate or become entangled with the other disputes.

"This is a matter that should be dealt with on its own merits ... and that is how we are approaching it," British Prime Minister Tony Blair's office said.

Iran's ambassador to Iraq, Hassan Kazemi Qomi, told The Associated Press in a telephone interview from Baghdad that there was no connection between the capture of the British sailors and marines and other disputes between the West and Iran. "They entered Iranian territorial waters and were arrested," Qomi said. "It has nothing to do with other issues."

A 1975 treaty between Iran and Iraq set their border as running down the center of the Shatt al-Arab, but Saddam Hussein canceled the treaty before invading Iran in 1980 and setting of a devastating war. Iran claims the border runs along the deepest parts of the river.

At U.N. headquarters in New York, deputy spokeswoman Marie Okabi said the United Nations had not become involved in the current dispute. "This matter is between the countries involved," she said.

Calls for the release of the Britons also came from the European Union, Iraq and the United States, under whose command the military search team was serving when it was captured.

On Monday, Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari told Iranian Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki that the personnel were seized in Iraqi waters and said they should be released.

Meanwhile, Iranian state TV said Iran was open to negotiations over its nuclear program despite its decision to partially cut cooperation with the U.N. atomic watchdog agency in response to the

U.N. Security Council's vote Saturday to approve additional sanctions on Tehran.

"Iran looks at negotiations as the only solution to the nuclear case," it said.

The sanctions are meant to persuade Iran to suspend uranium enrichment as demanded by the council and underline its growing international isolation. The United States has warned of even tougher penalties if Tehran doesn't comply.

Comments

  • sjackson, Jun 18, 2008 at 08:59 AM PDT said:

    iraqi's, iraninans, syrians,...they are all hostile towards the west. US should attack iran and get the regime changed there. that is the only way there will be peace in the middle east

  • akbar, Jun 05, 2008 at 12:15 PM PDT said:

    US and UK always lie to the world...

View all 3 comments

Comment on this content

Create, store, share and publish all your digital stuff

Sign Up » it's free

or learn more »

Web Snippet

Save bookmarks in a place where you can find it, store a snapshot of, share with friends and publish for all

Related Stuff

  • Iraqi Terrorist Gets Caught Dressed as a Bride

    This is comical!!! Iraqi police captured wanted terrorists dressed as a bride and a groom and trying to flee. Apparently, the young terrorist was dressed in a white bridal gown with a veil over his fa...

  • Painful Arrest

    Ouch!! What a painful way to get arrested by the cops!...

  • Soldier survives a knife attack in Iraq

    This is an amazing story of a US soldier surviving a knife attack - a 9 inch knife that pierces half way into his head!! This clearly proves the sacrifices our soldiers are making in restoring and mai...

  • Lies, Damned Lies and The White House?

    Is Iran providing sniper rifles to Iraqi insurgents? Not a single one of the guns in question -- Steyr-Mannlicher HS50 .50-cals -- "has ever been documented as having been captured from Sunni ins...

  • Images of Beautiful Sheikh Zayed Mosque, Abu Dhabi

    MAGNIFICENT:

    It is the third largest mosque in the world, located in Abu Dhabi, the capital of the United Arab Emirates. It is named after Sheikh Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan, the founder and the...

  • Quick Arrest Technique for Small and Female Police Officers

    I found this clip on the Internet. I loved it and so, I am reproducing it here.

    This is an excellent tactic for small police officers to use when apprehending a larger suspect. The technique us...

  • Why the British Read Newspapers

    Check these clips out to figure out why the British read tabloids and newspapers! The sizzling stories are simply irresistible!...

  • US Army Tank Crushes a Civilian Car in Iraq

    This is lawlessness...who said Iraq is safer for the common man there...the US military there is now the local mafia - the crooks in uniform. It is time for the occupying force to get out of Iraq....

  • British Gas and Electricity Industry Glossary

    A gas and electricity industry jargon buster...

  • English Forts (Castles)

    List of medieval castles in England. The list excludes the post-15th century 'castles,' which are actually country homes and were not intended to have any military function....

© Cylive 2006-2007 about | faq | tour | blog | feeds | terms | privacy | contact

User-created content, unless source quoted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Public Domain License